Difference between revisions of "Epistle to the Hebrews"

From TheAlmightyGuru
Jump to: navigation, search
(Review)
(5 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
[[Image:Papyrus 12 - Front - Epistles to the Hebrews.jpg|thumb|256x256px|A copy of Hebrews 1:1, circa 250 CE.]]
 
[[Image:Papyrus 12 - Front - Epistles to the Hebrews.jpg|thumb|256x256px|A copy of Hebrews 1:1, circa 250 CE.]]
  
The '''''Epistle to the Hebrews''''', often named simply, '''''Hebrews''''', is a letter written, not to an individual, but to a general Hebrew audience. The letter is estimated to have been written around 80–90 CE.
+
The '''Epistle to the Hebrews''', often named simply, '''Hebrews''', is the nineteenth book of the [[New Testament]]. It is a letter written in ancient Greek around 80-90 CE. Church tradition says the letter was written to a Hebrew audience and ascribes the letter to Paul the Apostle, but historians doubt it. The letter is mostly a critique of the [[Tanakh]].
  
==Authorship==
+
==Authorship and Dating==
 
While many Christian churches believe the author is Paul the Apostle, most New Testament scholars disagree and consider the author unknown; their reasons are numerous:
 
While many Christian churches believe the author is Paul the Apostle, most New Testament scholars disagree and consider the author unknown; their reasons are numerous:
* Of the letters believed to be the genuine work of Paul, in fact, even the fraudulent letters, Paul always identifies himself at the beginning of the letter. In this epistle, he does not.
+
* Of the letters believed to be the genuine work of Paul, in fact, even the fraudulent letters, Paul always identifies himself at the beginning of the letter. In this epistle, the author does not identify himself.
 
* The grammar and word-usage is markedly different between this and the other supposed genuine letters of Paul.
 
* The grammar and word-usage is markedly different between this and the other supposed genuine letters of Paul.
 
* The topic of the letter is also especially different from all of Paul's other letters.
 
* The topic of the letter is also especially different from all of Paul's other letters.
* Paul the Apostle supposedly died in the mid 60s CE, before the letter is estimated to have been written.
+
* Historians estimate the death of Paul the Apostle supposedly in the mid-60s CE, about 20 years before the letter is estimated to have been written.
 
* Even first century historians called the authorship of Hebrews into question, writing that they had no idea who wrote the letter.
 
* Even first century historians called the authorship of Hebrews into question, writing that they had no idea who wrote the letter.
 +
 +
The letter is estimated to have been written around 80–90 CE.
  
 
==Status==
 
==Status==
Line 17: Line 19:
 
===Good===
 
===Good===
 
* There's a useful definition of ''faith'': "Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen." (11:1 KJV). Of course, this negates those apologists who use ''faith'' to mean a demonstrated belief.
 
* There's a useful definition of ''faith'': "Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen." (11:1 KJV). Of course, this negates those apologists who use ''faith'' to mean a demonstrated belief.
* Scholars often say this letter was written for a Hebrew audience, but it reads more like a critique of the Torah. In the Torah, God demands animal sacrifice to annul your sins and loves the sweet smell of burning offal, in this letter God doesn't like the smell, doesn't want sacrifice, and it doesn't annul your sins anyway, only a human sacrifice can do that (chapter 9). The author says ceremonial foods have no value (13:9-10) even though God demands them all throughout the Torah. While I prefer these revisions, in order for them to be true, it means that the Hebrews have been completely wrong about the Torah for centuries.
+
* Church tradition says this letter was written for a Hebrew audience, but it reads more like a critique of the Torah. In the Torah, Yahweh demands animal sacrifice to annul your sins and loves the sweet smell of burning offal, in this letter Yahweh doesn't like the smell, doesn't want sacrifice, and it doesn't annul your sins anyway, only a human sacrifice can do that (chapter 9). The author says ceremonial foods have no value (13:9-10) even though Yahweh demands them all throughout the Torah. While I prefer these revisions, in order for them to be true, it means that the Torah is wrong, and that people were believing a false doctrine for centuries.
  
 
===Bad===
 
===Bad===
 
* I found the letter to be pretty dull over all, especially the beginning which is just mindless praise.
 
* I found the letter to be pretty dull over all, especially the beginning which is just mindless praise.
* The author warns against people who are sexually immoral and godless and cites Esau as an example (12:16). However, Esau was neither of these things, he was just a starving man who was conned out of his magical inheritance by his brother Isaac (Genesis 25, 27).
+
* The author warns against people who are sexually immoral and godless and cites Esau as an example (12:16). However, Esau was neither of these things, he was just a starving man who was conned out of his magical inheritance by his brother [[Esau and Isaac|Isaac]] (Genesis 25, 27).
  
 
===Ugly===
 
===Ugly===
* Much of the letter reads like a personal commentary on the Old Testament presented as fact. The author is basically saying, "these passages definitely mean what ''I'' know they mean," however, the author gives no demonstrable reason for how they know their interpretation is correct, and, in many cases, the author's interpretation is very different from a forthright interpretation.  
+
* Much of the letter reads like a personal commentary on the [[Tanakh]] presented as fact. The author is basically saying, "these passages definitely mean what ''I'' know they mean," however, just like modern day believers, the author gives no demonstrable reason for how they know their interpretation is correct, and, in many cases, the author's interpretation is very different from a forthright interpretation.  
 
* The letter ends with every dictator's dream passage, "Obey your leaders and submit to their authority!" (13:17)
 
* The letter ends with every dictator's dream passage, "Obey your leaders and submit to their authority!" (13:17)
  
 
==Links==
 
==Links==
* [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistle_to_the_Hebrews en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistle_to_the_Hebrews] - Wikipedia.
+
{{Link|Wikipedia|https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Epistle_to_the_Hebrews}}
 +
{{Link|GoodReads|https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/43619341-hebrews-kjv}}
 +
{{Link|ProjectGutenberg|https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/8058}}
 +
{{Link|LibriVox|https://librivox.org/group/360}}
 +
 
 
* [https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Hebrews+1-12&version=NIV biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Hebrews+1-12&version=NIV] - Bible Gateway.
 
* [https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Hebrews+1-12&version=NIV biblegateway.com/passage/?search=Hebrews+1-12&version=NIV] - Bible Gateway.
* [https://librivox.org/group/360 librivox.org/group/360] - LibriVox - King James Version.
 
 
* [https://librivox.org/group/220 librivox.org/group/220] - LibriVox - American Standard Version.
 
* [https://librivox.org/group/220 librivox.org/group/220] - LibriVox - American Standard Version.
 
* [https://librivox.org/group/383 librivox.org/group/383] - LibriVox - World English Translation.
 
* [https://librivox.org/group/383 librivox.org/group/383] - LibriVox - World English Translation.

Revision as of 16:38, 21 May 2019

A copy of Hebrews 1:1, circa 250 CE.

The Epistle to the Hebrews, often named simply, Hebrews, is the nineteenth book of the New Testament. It is a letter written in ancient Greek around 80-90 CE. Church tradition says the letter was written to a Hebrew audience and ascribes the letter to Paul the Apostle, but historians doubt it. The letter is mostly a critique of the Tanakh.

Authorship and Dating

While many Christian churches believe the author is Paul the Apostle, most New Testament scholars disagree and consider the author unknown; their reasons are numerous:

  • Of the letters believed to be the genuine work of Paul, in fact, even the fraudulent letters, Paul always identifies himself at the beginning of the letter. In this epistle, the author does not identify himself.
  • The grammar and word-usage is markedly different between this and the other supposed genuine letters of Paul.
  • The topic of the letter is also especially different from all of Paul's other letters.
  • Historians estimate the death of Paul the Apostle supposedly in the mid-60s CE, about 20 years before the letter is estimated to have been written.
  • Even first century historians called the authorship of Hebrews into question, writing that they had no idea who wrote the letter.

The letter is estimated to have been written around 80–90 CE.

Status

I own several English translations of this letter, and have read it the NIV translation.

Review

Good

  • There's a useful definition of faith: "Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen." (11:1 KJV). Of course, this negates those apologists who use faith to mean a demonstrated belief.
  • Church tradition says this letter was written for a Hebrew audience, but it reads more like a critique of the Torah. In the Torah, Yahweh demands animal sacrifice to annul your sins and loves the sweet smell of burning offal, in this letter Yahweh doesn't like the smell, doesn't want sacrifice, and it doesn't annul your sins anyway, only a human sacrifice can do that (chapter 9). The author says ceremonial foods have no value (13:9-10) even though Yahweh demands them all throughout the Torah. While I prefer these revisions, in order for them to be true, it means that the Torah is wrong, and that people were believing a false doctrine for centuries.

Bad

  • I found the letter to be pretty dull over all, especially the beginning which is just mindless praise.
  • The author warns against people who are sexually immoral and godless and cites Esau as an example (12:16). However, Esau was neither of these things, he was just a starving man who was conned out of his magical inheritance by his brother Isaac (Genesis 25, 27).

Ugly

  • Much of the letter reads like a personal commentary on the Tanakh presented as fact. The author is basically saying, "these passages definitely mean what I know they mean," however, just like modern day believers, the author gives no demonstrable reason for how they know their interpretation is correct, and, in many cases, the author's interpretation is very different from a forthright interpretation.
  • The letter ends with every dictator's dream passage, "Obey your leaders and submit to their authority!" (13:17)

Links

Link-Wikipedia.png  Link-GoodReads.png  Link-ProjectGutenberg.png  Link-LibriVox.png