Difference between revisions of "God at the end of the rainbow"

From TheAlmightyGuru
Jump to: navigation, search
(Created page with "'''''God At the End of the Rainbow''''' is a theological problem which highlights the limited thinking of older religions and the evolution of realm of the gods. As we look fu...")
 
(12 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
'''''God At the End of the Rainbow''''' is a theological problem which highlights the limited thinking of older religions and the evolution of realm of the gods. As we look further back in history, the dwelling place of gods becomes more and more mundane.
+
[[Image:Jean-Léon Gérôme - c. 1895-1900 - Moses On Mount Sinai.jpg|thumb|256x256px|Yahweh is associated with a volcanic mountain in the [[Book of Exodus]].]]
  
Going back to some of the oldest religions, around 3,000 years ago, gods lived in places inaccessible to the people of the day. The ancient Greeks believed their gods lived on [[Wikipedia:Mount Olympus#Religion_and_mythology|Mount Olympus]], the ancient Hindus believed their gods lived on [[Wikipedia:Mount Meru|Mount Meru]], those ancient Hebrews who worshiped Yahweh believed he lived atop [[Wikipedia:Biblical Mount Sinai|Mount Sinai]], while those who worshiped Elohim believed he lived atop [[Wikipedia:Mount Horeb|Mount Horeb]]. It's not always mountains either: [[Wikipedia:Hapi (Nile god)|Hapi]], one of the Egyptian Nile gods, lived among the caverns at the source of the Nile.
+
'''God at the end of the rainbow''' is a theological problem which highlights the limited thinking of people in older religions and the evolution of the home of the gods. As we look further back in history, the dwelling place of gods becomes more mundane. Generally speaking, this problem highlights a [[moving the goal-posts]] type fallacy.
  
However, as people began to expand across the land and climb the mountains, the idea of gods living on earth seemed a little silly, so beliefs evolved. Around 2,000 years ago the first Christians believed their god lived up in the clouds ([[First Epistle to the Thessalonians|I Thessalonians]] 4:17).
+
Going back around 3,000 years ago to some of the oldest surviving religions, the gods lived in places inaccessible to morals. The ancient Greeks believed their gods lived on [[Wikipedia:Mount Olympus#Religion_and_mythology|Mount Olympus]], the ancient Hindus believed their gods lived on [[Wikipedia:Mount Meru|Mount Meru]], those ancient Hebrews who worshiped Yahweh believed he lived atop [[Wikipedia:Biblical Mount Sinai|Mount Sinai]], while those who worshiped Elohim believed he lived atop [[Wikipedia:Mount Horeb|Mount Horeb]]. It's not always mountains either: [[Wikipedia:Hapi (Nile god)|Hapi]], one of the Egyptian Nile gods, was believed to live among the many caverns far away at the source of the Nile. Necessity requires the home of the gods to be where mortals can't reach. However, as people began to expand across the land and climb to the tops of mountains, they failed to see any gods, and the idea of gods living on the boring old earth seemed a little childish, so religious beliefs evolved.
  
In turn, people invented balloons, gliders, and other flying machines, and the idea of gods living in the clouds seemed a little silly, so beliefs evolved. 200 years ago, Latter Day Saints and Mormons believed their god lived on a distant planet called [[Wikipedia:Kolob|Kolob]].
+
Around 2,000 years ago religions claimed their gods lived way up in the clouds where no mortal could ever reach. This is what the early Christians believed, ([[First Epistle to the Thessalonians|I Thessalonians]] 4:17), and, in the Turkish religion of [[Wikipedia:Tengrism|Tengrism]], the god Tengri lived in the sky as well. Over time, people invented gliders, hot-air balloons, and other early flying machines, and the idea of gods living in the clouds seemed a little childish, so religious beliefs evolved.
  
Then, people developed powerful telescopes, and launched probes to the various planets in our solar system, and the idea of gods living on another planet seemed a little silly, so beliefs evolved. Most modern religious believers now claim that their gods live outside of the material universe entirely.
+
200 years ago, Latter Day Saints and Mormons believed their god lived on a distant planet called [[Wikipedia:Kolob|Kolob]], where no mortal could ever reach. Then, scientists developed powerful telescopes and launched probes to the various planets in our solar system, and landed on the Moon, and the idea of gods living on other planets seemed a little childish, so religious beliefs evolved.
  
And so, just like you can never get to the end of the rainbow, you can never get to the home of the gods; they're always living just out of reach.
+
Now, gods don't live on mountains, or in the sky, or even on other planets. Instead, most modern religious believers claim that their gods live in a spirit realm where no living mortal can ever ever go. Each time the home of the gods was in danger of being reached by mortals it was necessary for religious beliefs to evolve and push the home of the gods out just a bit further. Just as you can never get to the end of the rainbow, you can never get to the home of the gods; they're always living just out of reach.
 +
 
 +
Another way to make this case is by saying the [[teleological argument|fine tuning argument]] actually applies to the gods themselves.
  
  
 
[[Category: Atheism]]
 
[[Category: Atheism]]
 
[[Category: Religion]]
 
[[Category: Religion]]
 +
[[Category: Greek Mythology]]
 +
[[Category: Judaism]]
 +
[[Category: Christianity]]
 +
[[Category: Mormonism]]

Revision as of 09:07, 17 May 2022

Yahweh is associated with a volcanic mountain in the Book of Exodus.

God at the end of the rainbow is a theological problem which highlights the limited thinking of people in older religions and the evolution of the home of the gods. As we look further back in history, the dwelling place of gods becomes more mundane. Generally speaking, this problem highlights a moving the goal-posts type fallacy.

Going back around 3,000 years ago to some of the oldest surviving religions, the gods lived in places inaccessible to morals. The ancient Greeks believed their gods lived on Mount Olympus, the ancient Hindus believed their gods lived on Mount Meru, those ancient Hebrews who worshiped Yahweh believed he lived atop Mount Sinai, while those who worshiped Elohim believed he lived atop Mount Horeb. It's not always mountains either: Hapi, one of the Egyptian Nile gods, was believed to live among the many caverns far away at the source of the Nile. Necessity requires the home of the gods to be where mortals can't reach. However, as people began to expand across the land and climb to the tops of mountains, they failed to see any gods, and the idea of gods living on the boring old earth seemed a little childish, so religious beliefs evolved.

Around 2,000 years ago religions claimed their gods lived way up in the clouds where no mortal could ever reach. This is what the early Christians believed, (I Thessalonians 4:17), and, in the Turkish religion of Tengrism, the god Tengri lived in the sky as well. Over time, people invented gliders, hot-air balloons, and other early flying machines, and the idea of gods living in the clouds seemed a little childish, so religious beliefs evolved.

200 years ago, Latter Day Saints and Mormons believed their god lived on a distant planet called Kolob, where no mortal could ever reach. Then, scientists developed powerful telescopes and launched probes to the various planets in our solar system, and landed on the Moon, and the idea of gods living on other planets seemed a little childish, so religious beliefs evolved.

Now, gods don't live on mountains, or in the sky, or even on other planets. Instead, most modern religious believers claim that their gods live in a spirit realm where no living mortal can ever ever go. Each time the home of the gods was in danger of being reached by mortals it was necessary for religious beliefs to evolve and push the home of the gods out just a bit further. Just as you can never get to the end of the rainbow, you can never get to the home of the gods; they're always living just out of reach.

Another way to make this case is by saying the fine tuning argument actually applies to the gods themselves.