Shanghai (video game)

From TheAlmightyGuru
Jump to: navigation, search
The Western PC box art.

Shanghai is a mahjong solitaire puzzle video game developed and published by Activision initially for the Macintosh Classic in July 1986, and then ported to 20 other platforms. This was the first game in the Shanghai series and the first popular mahjong solitaire game to be released in the West.

Personal

While perusing the Master System library, I saw this game. I knew it was a mahjong solitaire game from its title, and was curious to see what it had going for it. I played it until I beat it on 2022-02-10 and discovered, sadly, it was just the basic game. The next day, curious to see how the home computer ports fared, so I played and beat the Apple IIgs version. I later beat the TurboGrafx-16 on 2022-09-20.

I don't own this game.

Review

Video Game Review Icon - Enjoyment.png Video Game Review Icon - Control.png Video Game Review Icon - Appearance.png Video Game Review Icon - Sound.png Video Game Review Icon - Replayability.png
3 4 4 4 6

Best Version: FM Towns

— This section contains spoilers! —

Good

  • The game competently enforces the rules of mahjong solitaire.
  • For the 16-bit ports, the graphics are attractive. For the some of the 8-bit ports, they're passable.
  • Several of the ports have fitting Chinese-inspired music including for the Lynx, Master System, NES, and PC Engine.
  • The better ports have enjoyable ending animations.
  • The PC Engine port includes a multi-player mode where each player has only a limited time to find a match.

Bad

  • The game deals the tiles out randomly. While this is true to the original game, it results in a large percentage of games being impossible to win. Later adaptions take advantage of the using a computer to deal the tiles in matched pairs ensuring that every game is beatable (provided you make all the right moves).
  • Some of the ports don't simulate the 3D raised effect of the tiles which makes them much harder to play (Atari 8-bit, Atari ST, Commodore 64, MS-DOS, NES, PCjr ports), while others do it very poorly (Apple II, Commodore 64). Also, some ports have such a low resolution, the tiles are difficult to read.
  • None of the ports have great music, some don't feature background music while playing, a lot don't even have music at all.

Ugly

  • For nearly every port, the game is just the most basic possible version of mahjong solitaire. It has only the standard turtle layout with no other options. To make an American analogy, it would be like buying a solitaire game and having it only feature standard Klondike solitaire with no other different game styles. This probably would have been acceptable in the West in 1986 when the game first came out since so few would have been familiar with mahjong solitaire, but, by the time the last ports came out in 1990, they should have expanded the game, especially since the superior hardware could handle more.
  • The MS-DOS and PCjr ports have really bad controls. They don't support a mouse, so, and without a joystick, keyboard movement is painfully slow.

Media

Box Art

Documents

Graphics

Videos

Longplay - Lynx.
Longplay - Master System.
Longplay - NES.
Longplay - PC Engine.
Longplay - Sharp X68000.
Game play - Amiga.
Game play - Apple II.
Game play - Apple IIgs.
Game play - Atari 8-bit.
Game play - Atari ST.
Game play - Commodore 64.
Game play - MS-DOS.
Game play - MSX2.
Game play - PC98.
Game play - TRS CoCo.
Game play - Sharp X1.

Representation

Bechdel test?FailThere are no characters.
Strong female character?FailThere are no characters.
Strong non-white character?FailThere are no characters.
Queer character?FailThere are no characters.

Links

Link-MobyGames.png  Link-Wikipedia.png  Link-StrategyWiki.png  Link-GameFAQs.png  Link-TCRF.png