Difference between revisions of "The Wind In the Willows"

From TheAlmightyGuru
Jump to: navigation, search
(Bad)
Line 3: Line 3:
 
'''''The Wind In the Willows''''' is a children's novel written by [[Kenneth Grahame]] and first published on 1908-06-15. The book is about four anthropomorphic animals, a mole, water rat, toad, and badger who live along a river and have adventures and share in their friendship.
 
'''''The Wind In the Willows''''' is a children's novel written by [[Kenneth Grahame]] and first published on 1908-06-15. The book is about four anthropomorphic animals, a mole, water rat, toad, and badger who live along a river and have adventures and share in their friendship.
  
My first experience with this story was from the 1988 cartoon ''[[Wind In the Willows (1988 film)|Wind In the Willows]]'' which I saw as a child. I later saw Disney's ''[[The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad]]''. Knowing the story was well-received, I decided to read it.
+
My first experience with this story was from the 1988 cartoon ''[[Wind In the Willows (1988 film)|Wind In the Willows]]'' which I saw as a child. I later saw Disney's ''[[The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad]]''. Knowing the story was well-received, I decided to read it, but was quite disappointed.
  
 
==Status==
 
==Status==

Revision as of 13:17, 24 June 2019

Hardcover, UK, 1st edition.

The Wind In the Willows is a children's novel written by Kenneth Grahame and first published on 1908-06-15. The book is about four anthropomorphic animals, a mole, water rat, toad, and badger who live along a river and have adventures and share in their friendship.

My first experience with this story was from the 1988 cartoon Wind In the Willows which I saw as a child. I later saw Disney's The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad. Knowing the story was well-received, I decided to read it, but was quite disappointed.

Status

I do not own this book. I am listening to an audio book recording.

Review

Good

  • There are some pretty good romantic descriptions of nature and adventure. For instance I like how Grahame describes the compulsion birds feel to migrate.

Bad

  • The book is very slow. Some portions, like when Rat and Mole stumble upon Badger's door, are even tedious.
  • The three side-stories are totally unnecessary and only slow the story down further. Also, I don't care for the inclusion of Pan. Either set your story in a fantasy world or a natural world (with anthropomorphic animals), but don't dabble.
  • The "battle" at Toad Hall was far too easy. The weasels and stoats are tricked and beaten with barely a fight, and they make no attempt to recapture the residence even after they realize they've been tricked.

Ugly

  • Toad's escape from prison is ridiculous. What kind of society allows prison escapees to just return to their homes just because they successfully evaded recapture?
  • Toad is a horrible person. He's constantly lying to his friends, robbing innocent people, destroying property, and endangering the lives of bystanders. He really does belong in prison, and his friends are wrong to protect and coddle him.

Adaptions

Released Title Notes
1949-10-05 The Adventures of Ichabod and Mr. Toad
1988-??-?? Wind In the Willows

Links

Link-Wikipedia.png  Link-GoodReads.png  Link-ProjectGutenberg.png  Link-LibriVox.png  Link-TVTropes.png